I received my replacement foam pads for my handlebar mounted phone caddy. After cleaning off the old adhesive residue with denatured alcohol the new pads went in place and stuck tight. They are very effective. I was skeptical of using a phone caddy that only gripped my device from the sides but this really works! I do have a otter box case and the pads seem to hold on exceptionally well. The non-fabric pad revision is definitely better. Thanks guys!

These replacement gripper pads are a totally different animal from the original factory pads. These pads have a griper texture compared to the cloth texture on the factory-installed ones. This should be an improvement over the factory ones; time will tell.